As the California Department of Finance studies the possibility of California imposing a new tax or penalty on large employers with workers who receive Medi-Cal benefits, a similar charge imposed by the state of New Jersey is being challenged on the grounds that it violates employers’ due process rights and interferes with federally regulated employer-sponsored health plans.
The California study is required by SB 177 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review Committee), signed into law July 6 by Governor Gavin Newsom.
“On or before March 1, 2027, the Department of Finance shall present to the Joint Legislative Budget Committee one or more options for holding the state’s largest corporations accountable for the taxpayer costs of their employees enrolled in the Medi-Cal program,” the legislation states. “When a big corporation relies on Medi-Cal to provide their employees with health insurance, they are relying on what amounts to taxpayer subsidies to gain the competitive advantage of a healthy workforce.”
Under the legislation, one of the options presented by the Department of Finance must include “a premium paid by employers with at least 250 employees to offset taxpayer costs of their employees enrolled in the Medi-Cal program who are not offered employer health coverage.” The legislation does not specify that the 250-employee threshold would be based on employees within this state.
SB 177, which contained a $10,000 appropriation to allow it to take effect immediately as a budget trailer bill, provides that the report will not be required if the federal government repeals provisions enacted in 2025 to establish work and community engagement requirements to qualify for Medicaid (the healthcare program, jointed funded by the federal government and states, known as Medi-Cal in California).
On August 20, the Restaurant Law Center (RLC), together with the National Retail Federation, the American Hotel & Lodging Association, and the International Franchise Association, filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey challenging New Jersey’s charge on employers with workers who receive Medicaid benefits.
The New Jersey Employer Healthcare Assistance Contribution Act requires employers in New Jersey with 50 or more employees enrolled in the state’s Medicaid program to pay an annual “fee” for each employee and each of the employee’s dependents who receive Medicaid benefits. The charge ranges from $325 per employee and dependent for companies with 50 to 250 employees, up to $725 per employee and dependent for companies with 500 or more workers.
A “dependent” is defined to include an employee’s unmarried children up to the age of 31. The suit notes that “many healthcare plans nationwide define a ‘dependent’ as only including a child up to age 26.”
The New Jersey law contains several exemptions. The “fee” will not be assessed for: employees and dependents who are covered by Medicaid due to a developmental disability, an intellectual disability, or a permanent physical disability; workers employed by the employer for less than 90 days at the time the “fee” is determined; employees who work part-time, on a per diem basis, or who are temporary employees; or seasonal employees.
If the New Jersey law survives the legal challenge, the first round of assessments will be issued by March 1, based on Medicaid enrollment as of the end of this year. Payment of the “fee” would be due by April 15, the traditional deadline for tax payments.
The suit alleges that the statute is unlawful for several reasons:
- ERISA Preemption: The law interferes with federally regulated employer-sponsored health plans by effectively pressuring employers to alter plan design, eligibility requirements, and coverage decisions. The suit asserts that these issues are governed by federal law under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and cannot be dictated by the state.
- Due Process Violations: The law requires employers to pay assessments based on information the state does not disclose, while placing the burden on employers to challenge those assessments. Employers are not provided with sufficient information to verify whether an assessment is accurate.
“The law does not provide a meaningful opportunity for an employer to obtain a determination of the accuracy and validity of the fee assessed against the employer and instead invites arbitrary enforcement of the law,” the suit asserts. “… [T]he law only requires the New Jersey Department of the Treasury’s Division of Revenue and Enterprise Services to inform employers of the purported number of employees and dependents enrolled in the Medicaid program, without providing their names or other information the employer would need to verify whether the employer was properly and accurately assessed the correct fee and, if necessary, to appeal the fee assessed by the State. Further, the Act prohibits the State from disclosing individually identifiable information about the employees and dependents for whom the employer was assessed a fee, thereby rendering any appeal rights meaningless.”
Additionally, the suit notes: “In industries where the same employee may work for multiple employers, there is no mechanism under the Act for preventing multiple employers from being charged what is supposed to be an annual fee tied to a single employee and their dependents. When both parents work for different employers, the Act provides no mechanism for preventing multiple employers from being charged a fee for the same dependents.”
- Conflict With Federal Law: The New Jersey law effectively requires employers to seek information from employees and their family members that may implicate federal privacy and anti-discrimination protections.
“The Act places on the employer the burden of proving that the assessment was incorrect, but an employer does not know whether its employees – or the dependents of its employees – are enrolled in Medicaid or the reasons why employees or dependents may be enrolled in Medicaid (e.g., income level, physical disability, intellectual disability, etc.). In vindicating their appeal rights, employers subject to the Act’s fee assessment would need to question any and all employees who declined anything other than ‘family coverage’ option under the employer’s own healthcare plan so as to determine whether (a) the employee is on Medicaid; (b) the employee has any dependents on Medicaid; (c) the employee or dependent actually incurred a medical claim and received Medicaid benefits from the State; (d) whether the employee or any dependent has a developmental, intellectual, or physical disability that would exempt the employer from the fee assessment; and (e) the dependents are 31 years or older and not capable of self-support so as to qualify as a dependent under the Act. … Put simply, the Act provides an illusory appeal right to employers, leaving them a Hobson’s Choice: the employer must (a) pay the assessed fee, or (b) violate federal laws, such as the ADA [Americans With Disabilities Act] and GINA [Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act], while pursuing the administrative appeal and questioning its employees regarding their or their dependents’ Medicaid coverage and grounds for it.”
The lawsuit seeks a declaration that the act is invalid, along with injunctive relief preventing New Jersey from enforcing it.
Other states have attempted similar laws, but courts have struck them down or legislatures have repealed or substantially modified them. Maryland’s law was struck down by a federal court in 2006 as being preempted by ERISA, and Massachusetts repealed a similar assessment on employers.
The brief analysis of SB 177 prepared by legislative staff before the Senate’s floor vote – the only legislative analysis of the bill – did not include any discussion of the underlying policy’s potential violations of federal law and/or due process rights.